The A-Game

No Sift next week. The next new posts will appear on November 30.

That’s what’s so cool about this. It’s a team, where everybody is bringing their A-game to whatever it is they do best. When you do that, you create new things.

– Heather Cox Richardson

This week’s featured posts are “Is Trump really President now?” and “Congressional Democrats try to organize themselves“.

Ongoing stories

  • Trump’s assault on American democracy. Trump is back to challenging the election results, based on nothing but his feelings. “Does anybody really believe that this ‘Election’ was honest. How could the Polls be so wrong???” It seems unlikely this could escalate into another January 6, but you never know.
  • Climate change. COP 31, the 31st meeting of the Conference of Parties that produced the Paris Accords in 2015, will be meeting in Turkey until Friday. It comes at a time when the power requirements of the AI build-out are causing nations to miss their fossil-fuel reduction goals.
  • Israel/Palestine. There’s still no new government in Israel. Talks towards a “unity government” bringing both major candidates together folded yesterday.
  • Ukraine. Ukrainian and Russian negotiators met in Abu Dhabi this week. This was the first meeting since February, and the only tangible achievement was a prisoner exchange. Disturbingly, the previous week Trump hinted at a broader agreement about “all of Europe”. Putin has been demanding NATO pull its forces back to where they were in the mid-1990s, i.e., abandon Poland and the Baltic republics. That Trump entertains this at all stabs NATO in the back. On The Steady State blog, former US diplomat Bruce Berton blames this on the naivety of Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff, neither of whom knows anything about … well, just about anything.

This week’s developments

This week’s biggest story was the Nvidia spy case

Everybody wants to cover this as a sex scandal — and there is some sex involved — but that’s not what’s important about it. This is:

  • Nvidia is a $4 trillion company.
  • More than that, it makes the kinds of highly advanced computer chips that are at the center of the AI build-out. If you’re using ChatGPT or Claude or some other AI application, probably your answers are being assembled on Nvidia chips somewhere. It’s widely believed in the industry that if you can’t get access to the most advanced chips, you’re going to fall behind your AI competitors. So when people tell you how important it is that the US beat China in “the AI race”, in part they’re depending on Nvidia continuing to produce the worlds best chips, and on US companies to get first access to them.
  • More than that, Nvidia is at the center of the “circular financing” that is funding the AI build-out. Wikipedia describes it like this:

A circular deal typically involves one company — often a chip manufacturer or cloud provider—taking an equity stake in, or extending financing to, a firm that in turn commits to buy that same company’s products or services. Nvidia has been described as “particularly aggressive” in this respect, investing in AI startups, funding infrastructure buildouts, and taking stakes in data-centre and “neocloud” companies that rent out access to its chips. Examples cited by Bloomberg include Nvidia’s investments in Nscale, Nebius, CoreWeave (in which it also agreed to buy $6.3 billion of cloud services), Safe Superintelligence and Naver, as well as up to $100 billion pledged toward OpenAI (of which it ultimately contributed $30 billion to a funding round) and up to $15 billion pledged jointly with Microsoft toward Anthropic. Similar dynamics have linked Microsoft and OpenAI (which has committed to purchase $250 billion of Microsoft cloud services), Amazon and Google with Anthropic, and AMD with both OpenAI and Anthropic.

Put that all together, and Nvidia may at the moment be the most important company in the world. The scandal is that Nvidia has been exposed to Chinese spying at the highest level: It’s long-time CEO, Jensen Huang, had an affair with a woman the FBI believes to be a Chinese spy.

Perhaps a bigger scandal is that the FBI knew about this and didn’t give Huang what is known as a “defensive briefing”; it didn’t tell Huang what they suspected and why.

The Trump administration also knew. Marco Rubio wrote a memo about this in the spring, before Trump’s trip to China in May. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, who has apparent conflicts of interest, seems to have blocked taking action.

and Democratic strategy in Congress

That’s the subject of one featured post.

and Mississippi

Scott Colum, who hardly anyone expected to get close in his Senate race, much less win, will be the first Black person Mississippi has sent to the Senate since Reconstruction. His race was close, but finally was called on Wednesday.

Colum is the 55th Democratic seat in the Senate. Probably the 56th is coming. At the moment, Mary Peltola sits just short of 50% of the counted vote. The remaining votes might put her over 50% and prevent invoking the instant runoff. However, she will almost certainly win in the run-off round, since she needs so few votes to go over 50%.

and tech screw-ups

Thursday, Microsoft services like Teams and Outlook went down, throwing a lot of the world’s businesses into temporary chaos. Full service wasn’t restored until Saturday. The explanation offered wasn’t that comforting:

“The incident was introduced by an issue during an earlier network capacity upgrade that surfaced following a recent network change,” Microsoft wrote. “We have addressed the underlying issue and continue to restore service to remaining customers and regions.”… First and foremost, Microsoft says the outage was not caused by a cyberattack. It blamed the problem on an “elevated load” on its infrastructure, where servers become over-whelmed with traffic. According to Microsoft, this happened because some servers failed, sending traffic to the remaining ones and causing them to overload.

This sounds a lot like electrical blackouts: Something fairly routine causes an initial failure, which then cascades through the network. Why this couldn’t happen again tomorrow is still a mystery to me.


Fortunately for Microsoft, everybody forgot about them by Friday, when the FAA grounded all US plane flights for three and a half hours.

The ground stop caused nearly 8,000 cancellations and more than 10,000 flights to be delayed across the United States, including cargo flights. The outage also affected international flights that transited United States airspace, including the heavy seasonal air traffic between Canada and Mexico, the Caribbean and Central America. … Although the nationwide ground stop was lifted on Friday evening, its effects continued into Saturday, 14 November, when more than 2,500 additional flights were canceled and hundreds more were delayed as airlines worked to restore normal operations. Passengers continued to face disruptions, with some having to make alternative travel and accommodation arrangements. The Associated Press reported that the effects of the shutdown could continue for several days.

Again, the underlying cause (at least as given) didn’t seem that unusual.

According to [Transportation Secretary] Sean Duffy, a newly installed router began to overload other routers with a thousand connection attempts every few seconds. The issue was connected to L3Harris, as a matter of routine maintenance, replacing obsolete copper wire with fiber optic at a remote FAA facility in southern Arkansas. The contractor has already completed roughly 70% of the conversion from copper to fiber.

L3Harris is “the contractor which owns the Federal Aviation Administration Telecommunications Infrastructure (FTI).” Again, network cascade effects lengthened the duration of the event.

Washington Examiner reporter Anna Giaratelli tweeted:

I’ve spoken with about 60 air traffic controllers tonight about what Sean Duffy said at the White House today. None of them are buying what he said because they said these types of switches that the FAA is doing, they don’t happen during the day, they don’t happen during busy times like a Friday afternoon.

Wikipedia adds:

On November 10, 2026, the FAA expanded an artificial intelligence (AI) air traffic management system, Strategic Management of Airspace, Routes and Trajectories (SMART), to all air centers. The FAA has denied this rollout as being a cause for the ground stop.

FAA Administrator Bryan Bedford said Saturday that normal operations were expected to resume by Sunday evening.

But it seems to be taking a bit longer.

But by 7 a.m. ET Monday, about 8,365 flights were delayed and 533 canceled nationwide, a dramatic drop from the 26,392 delayed and 2,858 canceled flights Sunday, according to the aviation data site FlightAware.


Of course, nothing is ever the Trump regime’s fault. Trump himself posted:

The Biden Administration was an FAA disaster. Everything they touched turned bad. Big money spent unwisely, making an old and broken system worse than when they began. We have the knowledge and plan for the Flight Control Systems, we need Congress to give the money, FAST!

As if he has had no influence over Congress these last two years.

Duffy used the incident to ask for another $50 billion.

Democrats have questioned why the Trump administration was requesting tens of billions of dollars in additional funding when it had spent only a fraction of the money already allocated by Congress. … “It’s really rich to hear the secretary pointing the fingers at Congress when Congress has given the administration what they asked for,” [Maryland Senator Chris] Van Hollen said Sunday. “If they need more, they should come up and justify it. I will support what is necessary to have a safe system and a reliable system.”

And the ranking Democratic member of the House Appropriations Committee posted this illustrative graphic.

and the Hegseth impeachment failed (for now)

Tuesday the House voted on Republican Thomas Massie’s resolution to impeach Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth. It voted 211-204 to send the resolution to the Judiciary Committee, effectively killing it for the rest of this session. The vote was essentially party-line, with Massie being the only Republican to back his resolution.

One controversy came out of the vote: 11 Democrats didn’t vote, enough to have passed the resolution and set up an impeachment trial in the Senate. The non-voting Democrats blamed an unusual traffic situation for holding them up. If the House leadership had wanted the resolution to pass, it could have held voting open until the missing members arrived.

I have two comments on this: First, Hegseth absolutely deserves impeachment. Several of the articles of impeachment are debatable, depending on what you believe about the constitutionality of the War Powers Act. But the one I find open-and-shut is Article V, Extrajudicial Killings. That’s about the strikes on boats that are suspected of smuggling drugs. More than 200 human beings have been killed this way, and I believe this is simply murder.

Second, I’m just as happy this resolution failed, because I want Democrats to be in charge of the Senate when Hegseth’s trial starts. We saw in the first Trump impeachment what a difference that makes. Republicans were able to have it both ways, claiming that the House committees hadn’t interviewed the most direct witnesses (who were refusing to talk), but then deciding not to subpoena them.

Democrats may or may not be able to raise the 67 Senate votes necessary to remove Hegseth, but they can at least assemble all the evidence if they’re in control of the process.


Both Hegseth and Trump said some truly horrifying things about the military this week.

In his Veteran’s Day speech, Trump announced “to the victor belong the spoils”. Phillips O’Brien comments:

Under Trump’s leadership, the US military should be seen more like a mercenary force whose job is to go around the world stealing from the weak and expropriating wealth into the USA. He is even boasting about this.

And here’s Hegseth:

Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth drew alarm from across the political spectrum Saturday night after reposting a clip of Secretary of State Marco Rubio attacking the International Criminal Court and adding what one critic argued was a “deeply un-American” seven-word message. “Stop quoting laws to MEN WITH SWORDS,” Hegseth wrote.

The quote is apparently from the Roman general Pompey, who ultimately got his head cut off by people who thought Caesar wanted that. Hegseth appears to be saying that might makes right, that if you have the swords, no moral or legal principles should apply.

This is not how the US military has ever operated. And if that’s the new rule, why shouldn’t the military overthrow the US government?

and you also might be interested in …

Montana overwhelmingly passed a ballot proposal to get corporate money out of state politics. The Montana Plan is an end-run around the Supreme Court’s Citizen United ruling, holding that since corporations are created by states, states can change their charters. The initiative removes the power to make political contributions from corporate charters.

The law is already being challenged in court, and will undoubtedly go back to the Supremes. The conservative majority will undoubtedly want to strike it down, but I’ll be curious to see how they do it without relying on some semi-metaphysical rights that corporations have, maybe from God.


I am one of those sports fans who often imagines that he’s smarter than the average bear. So I’ve occasionally thought about testing that belief by opening an account on a sports betting site like DraftKings or FanDuel. Rather than read a box score and tell myself “I knew that would happen”, I’d have a betting history that would prove objectively that I either do or don’t have better-than-average intuition.

The dark side of sports betting, though, is that people get addicted to it. And the problem gambler has the same relationship to the betting sites that alcoholics have to liquor companies: Most gamblers (like most drinkers) never develop a problem; but the ones who do are enormously profitable for the companies. Sports betting might not be a viable industry at all without gambling addicts.

The gambling sites are sensitive to this criticism, so their commercials include 800 numbers that problem gamblers can call, and maybe an occasional warning about “responsible gambling”, i.e., not betting more than you can afford to lose. Supposedly, their algorithms are on the look-out for signs of addiction and have safeguards. But they’re also trying to make the next wager as tempting as possible, so they are at best conflicted.

Jake Pearson at Pro Publica decided to test DraftKings. He did research into the patterns of problem gamblers, and then did his best to imitate them, just to see what would happen. What happened was that DraftKings loved him. He was awarded VIP status, which has a variety of perks. Even as one algorithm was telling him to slow down, another was sending promotional offers to his phone.

He wrote an article about that experience, which DraftKings mostly ignored. Then he made a 27-minute documentary video, which has gotten 7 million views. So they took immediate action: They canceled his account.


So the Supreme Court decided that many of Trump’s tariffs were illegal, and so the government has refunded many billions of dollars to the companies who paid those tariffs. Ultimately, though, the companies passed the costs on to their customers in the form of higher prices. So the US consumers really paid the tariffs.

You might imagine some companies would use their tariff refunds to benefit their customers somehow. But Pro Publica has discovered what they’re really doing: paying bonuses to their executives.

and let’s close with something that we’ll never really see happen

SNL put together a post-election ad for some of the nastiest campaigners.

Congressional Democrats try to organize themselves

Is new leadership worth the turmoil? And what should any leaders try to do?


The Democratic House and Senate minority leaders — Hakeem Jeffries and Chuck Schumer — are in line to become Speaker and Majority Leader once the new Democratic majorities take their seats in January. Unfortunately, they are two of the least popular figures in Washington. According the RCP polling averages, Jeffries’ approval rating is 11 points underwater (28% favorable, 39% unfavorable) while Schumer’s is even worse: 25% favorable and 49% unfavorable, for a net of -24%.

So ever since the midterm blue wave, Democrats have been debating: Can we do better? There are a few reasons not to ask this question:

  • You don’t fire your leadership after a big win.
  • A leadership battle allows the media to fire up the “Democrats is disarray” theme they love so much. Similarly: This is an inside-baseball story that distracts from Trump regime corruption, the war, the bad economy, and all the other favorable developments happening in the outside world
  • Leadership in Congress isn’t primarily about being popular or striking a charismatic figure on TV. Most of the action is behind the scenes: counting votes and figuring out what you can unite your caucus behind. Let the caucuses themselves decide who will do this best.

All those points are debatable. Schumer, in particular, has only a middling claim on the midterm success, which seems likely to net the Democrats a totally unexpected 56-44 majority. (The last two seats are just about decided. Scott Colum was declared the winner in Mississippi on Wednesday, while in Alaska Mary Peltola is right on the edge of a 50% total. She will either go over that total and win without calculating the instant-runoff, or will go into that runoff needing hardly any new votes. She might go over the top just because of the voters who didn’t name a second choice at all — that would change the number of total votes and maybe put her first-round total over 50%. Senator Fetterman is making noises about leaving the party, but no one cares.) Schumer gets some credit for recruiting good candidates, but he also recruited clunkers like Janet Mills in Maine and Haley Stevens in Michigan. He didn’t put money behind either Scott Colum in Mississippi (who narrowly won) or Angie Nixon in Florida (who narrowly lost), but few predicted either of those races would be close enough for some extra funding to matter.

The lack of a leadership battle will bring its own round of bad press, something like “You voted for change, but Democrats aren’t listening.”

I have some sympathy for the third point. Nancy Pelosi also wasn’t popular with progressive Democrats, but she was arguably the most effective speaker of my lifetime. Pelosi saw herself as the shepherd of an unruly flock, which she managed to keep together remarkably well. Just because you’re the leader doesn’t mean anyone will necessarily follow you, something a string of ineffective Republican speakers have made clear.

Still, the inside-baseball view of congressional leadership is maybe a step or two behind the times. In the absence of an incumbent President or clear front-runner for the presidency, the Party desperately needs a national spokesperson. Like it or not, Schumer and Jeffries will wind up in that role, and neither is suited for it. On the other hand, as fun as it would be to have someone as telegenic as AOC laying out an inspiring agenda … if she can’t unite the caucus behind it enough to get bills passed, what’s the point? Ideally you need both a vote-counting shepherd and a telegenic talking head on TV.

At the moment, no one has emerged to challenge Jeffries for the speakership. (To be honest, I don’t like the optics of staging a coup just before the first Black speaker is about to ascend.) But Senator Chris Van Hollen of Maryland is challenging Schumer for the majority leader job.

So who is this guy? Van Hollen has been in the Senate since 2017, in Congress since 2003, and in elected office since 1991. He’s 67 years old to Schumer’s 76-later-this-month. So this not “generational change” in any significant sense. He seems more progressive than Schumer, but is far from a firebrand. He started making a case for Medicare for All about a year ago. He called attention to the regime’s foreign-prison policy by flying to El Salvador to meet with Maryland resident Kilmar Abrego Garcia in the CECOT prison where Trump had illegally sent him.

Bernie Sanders wrote an op-ed endorsing him.

This is not a personality contest. This is a debate about the future of the Democratic party. It is a debate about whether the Democratic party remains a top-down party dominated by billionaire campaign contributors, inside-the-beltway consultants and 30-second TV ads, or whether we can transform it into a grassroots party of, by and for the working families of our country.

But it’s not clear how much of Bernie’s agenda Van Hollen actually shares. He is a critic of the Israeli government.

He has accused Israel of committing genocide in Gaza. Van Hollen has called for restrictions on U.S. military aid to Israel and worked to halt arms shipments to Israel. Israel has repeatedly denied accusations of genocide. Meanwhile, Schumer, who has led Senate Democrats since 2017, has a long history of support for Israel. He remains one of Washington’s most-prominent defenders of the U.S.-Israel relationship even as he has criticized Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s handling of the war in Gaza.

So there are differences between him and Schumer, but I don’t see Van Hollen as revolutionary, if that’s what you’re looking for.


Josh Marshall makes a worthwhile point: Changing Senate leadership is far less important than ending the filibuster, which neither Sanders nor Van Hollen have endorsed. [Correction: Van Hollen has called for abolishing the filibuster.]

One TPM reader just told me it’s crazy to get into a big fight about this now when President Trump’s veto makes this mostly moot. That is a credible argument; but I disagree. With the filibuster in place, you’re not going to be able to pass a bunch of popular bills that President Trump is forced to veto. And you’re not going to be able to put Senate Republicans on the spot and force them to vote against popular bills either. So a lot of what people want Democrats to do out of the gate next year isn’t actually going to happen. It’ll peter out in parliamentary minutiae. … As long as the Democratic caucus is an amorphous blob when it comes to the filibuster, sort of against it but not in a specific or definitive way, it’s impossible to grab on to, impossible to start dividing the caucus into supporters and opponents and begin pressuring or convincing members to shift from one column to the other.If you’re serious about ending the filibuster — and almost everything depends on it — you have to change that: you have to start identifying supporters and opponents, get them on the record. And you have to start doing it today because if you don’t you’ll roll into 2029 in the exact same situation, with this intractable barrier to progress which isn’t going anywhere any time soon.

Sanders offers the alternative of passing a reconciliation bill, which avoids the filibuster and so needs only a majority vote. But since you only get one or two shots at a reconciliation bill each year, they are the kind of big omnibus bills that are easy to veto. A targeted raise-the-minimum-wage bill is harder, because people know exactly what it means. Without the filibuster, you can make Trump veto something popular every week.


Democrats in Congress have an important decision to make before the new Congress takes office in January: The government runs out of money on December 11. Republicans will want to either pass another continuing resolution or push through a full-year budget. The big issue here is the Iran War: Should Democrats try to defund it now, and risk a government shutdown that will stretch through the holidays? Or wait for reinforcements to arrive in January? What’s the shortest continuing resolution that won’t spark a shutdown?

I’d like to hear Schumer and Van Hollen explain their strategies here.

Is Trump really President now?

Or is he just a figurehead for the Miller administration?


Last week, maybe I shouldn’t have ignored the flap over Trump naming Dana White, president of the Ultimate Fighting Championship, as his new press secretary. White has neither qualifications nor interest in the press secretary job, but on November 7, Trump posted this to Truth Social:

I am pleased to announce that the Great Dana White, a violent Fighter and Warrior, has been offered the job of Press Secretary of the United States. I have requested that he bring with him assistants, even though some are not from our Country, of Islam Makhachev, Khabib Nurmagomedov, Justin Gaethje, Daniel Cormier, Amanda Nunes, and Kayla Harris. We need these people to defend us against the Lunatic Left. Dana will be a Press Secretary like none other. Dana, please take the job! President DONALD J. TRUMP

After a lot of scrambling around for a sensible explanation of this bizarre announcement, somebody realized that there was another Dana White, who actually had some qualifications: In Trump’s first administration, she had been Assistant to the Secretary of Defense for Public Affairs, a position that involved handling the press. This sparked the “wrong Dana” theory: What if somebody told Trump that Dana White had been chosen to be the next press secretary, and he misinterpreted?

The White House quickly shut down this speculation. On the 8th, Trump claimed he was “only kidding” about the job offer, a claim Trump often makes when he has said something he wants to take back. Some other examples of Trump’s “joking” or “sarcasm” include the times he

I could go on.

At the time, I wrote off the Dana White incident as just another Trump-said-something-stupid story, the kind of thing I try not to waste my attention on. But what if he wasn’t joking? That would imply that Trump doesn’t choose his press secretaries, he’s just informed who they will be. And it raises the question: What other decisions are being made without Trump’s input? When is he the ventriloquist and when is he the dummy?

Right after the voters gave him a midterm spanking, Trump seemed cowed. Uncharacteristically, he said he accepted the election results, and that he would try to work with the new Democrats. And then, he named Stephen Miller his new chief of staff.

If you don’t follow cartoons, late-night comedy, and other pop culture commentary on politics, it’s hard to appreciate just how ubiquitous the Miller-as-vampire meme is. In part it’s that he’s as bald and pale as the 1922 movie version of Nosferatu, but there is also something not-quite-human about his manner. He lacks any notion of political tact, and virtually any challenge an interviewer presents makes him erupt into shouting: Miller is not to be conversed with, he is to be obeyed. During the last two years (and much of Trump’s first administration), any policy that was needlessly cruel or violent — turning ICE loose on city streets, separating immigrant children from their parents, disappearing undocumented nannies and landscapers into concentration camps — has had Miller’s fingerprints on it.

Trump, meanwhile, has been exhibiting increasing signs of dementia for many months. During the midterm campaign, he could not seem to focus on any issue the voters cared about, but instead talked constantly about his unpopular attempts to gild DC: the White House ballroom, his arch celebrating no triumph in particular, turning a well-used DC park into a world-class golf course. He even made his closing argument at the scene of one of his most trivial but embarrassing failures, the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool. Jon Stewart could hardly believe it.

That was the president of the United States, on the day before the midterms, choosing to make a speech at the Reflecting Pool to talk about the Reflecting Pool. No symbolism. No metaphors. Just straight-up pool maintenance. That was Donald Trump’s I-had-it-cleaned speech.

His line on the Iran War has changed from day to day, or sometimes within the same day: He is going to escalate and end Iranian civilization. He doesn’t need to escalate because a deal is imminent. He doesn’t need a deal because the war is already over — unless he decides to end civilization again.

Increasingly, he seems not to remember his own policies, possibly repeating whatever was said to him by the last person he talked to. Now that the last person is Miller, Trump is back to election denial.

And now, Miller has taken steps to control who can talk to the President at all.

[T]he new Chief, Miller, issued two memos. One prohibits lobbyists from meeting on White House grounds without prior approval of the White House Counsel, which means the lobbying will move across the street but also means that lobbyists can’t get into the White House and wander into the Oval Office, as famously happens. And the other “instituted new decentralized processes meant to empower individual cabinet secretaries” like Sean Duffy and Markwayne Mullin to implement policy.

Marcy Wheeler leans on MSNOW’s interpretation of what that means:

To streamline his policy operation, Miller plans to leave two senior roles unfilled, according to that memo obtained by MS NOW and confirmed by one of those sources with direct knowledge of the plans. Richard Walters, the deputy chief of staff for legislative political and public affairs, who announced his departure earlier this week, will not be directly replaced. Neither will Meghan Bauer, the White House Cabinet secretary, who is leaving her role, in which she served as an intermediary between the president and Cabinet secretaries seeking West Wing meetings. According to those sources, for access to the president, cabinet secretaries will now go directly to Miller.

In other words, neither lobbyists nor cabinet secretaries will have access to Trump without Miller’s approval. This has been pitched as a way to “empower” the secretaries to act without direction from the president. In practice, it seems to mean leaving Duffy and Mullin on their own to answer for screw-ups like the FAA ground stop.

We can’t be certain whether what we’ve seen in the last few days — with Duffy and Mullin stepping on their dicks as Stephen Miller lurks off to the side, watching — reflects the implementation of that memo “empowering” Reality TV Stars and plumbers.

But it is what we should expect when a power-hungry man hides the doddering liege on whom his own claim to power rests away in a room while his cabinet secretaries take the fall for the incompetence the President and his Chief ordered.

The Monday Morning Teaser

The world continues to adjust to the midterm elections and the seismic shift in American politics they represent. Today I’ll have two featured posts, focusing first on the White House’s adjustments, and then on congressional Democrats.

The White House has adjusted by making Stephen Miller the new chief of staff, directly contradicting what Trump was saying in the elections’ immediate aftermath, that he accepted the results and would try to work with Democrats. Miller takes over at a time when Trump looks increasingly demented, and seems not to want to bother with the annoying parts of governing a superpower. He clearly misses his Manhattan real-estate-mogul and Atlantic City casino-designer days, and so spends the bulk of his waking time on projects to gild Washington.

Previous CoS Susan Wiles, I suspect, did her best to bring necessary decisions to Trump’s attention. But Miller seems to realize the advantages to having a checked-out boss. He can run the government the way he wants, let Trump play with his construction toys to his heart’s content, and leave Natalie Harp to massage Trump’s ego. That’s all speculation, but I pull together the pieces of it in the first featured post “Is Trump really President now?”, which should be out shortly.

The second featured post “Congressional Democrats try to organize themselves” looks at the strategic choices Democrats need to make now — most notably whether Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries are the right people to lead their Senate and House majorities, but also the more immediate question of whether to challenge Iran War funding when the current government-funding agreement runs out in mid-December. I’ll try to get that out between 10 and 11 EST.

That still leaves a lot for the weekly summary to cover: the Nvidia scandal, the FAA ground stop, the Microsoft outage, the Hegseth impeachment, the final Senate races, and a few other things. As usual, that should appear sometime between noon and 1.

Working together, working against

nobody gives you a sweeping mandate like this because they want you to work with the people they just ran tf outta office

– Shiv Ramdas

This week’s featured post is “The Blue Wave came. What now?“

Ongoing stories

  • Trump’s assault on American democracy. Democracy struck back this week, as chronicled in the featured post. Some pundits may be tempted to claim Trump’s overwhelming defeat means that the assault-on-democracy theme was always overblown. But while Trump’s attempts to cheat may have come to little or nothing, that’s because they were beaten back in the courts and by a motivated electorate. When police stop a gang from robbing a bank, you don’t say “No harm done” and send them home to plot their next attempt.
  • Climate change. Climate change wasn’t a big issue in this campaign, but Trump’s wide-ranging assault on reality was. Climate change denial/minimization is one of the many ways the regime lies to us. Going forward, Democrats need to connect obvious lies like “the economy is booming”, “prices are going down”, and “Iran has been defeated” to claims that climate change is a hoax.
  • Israel/Palestine. Israel used to be admired by nearly all American voters, and any hint that a candidate might not like Israel or the current Israeli government was quickly punished. That’s not true any more. In Israel itself, the anti-Netanyahu coalition has been given the first chance to form a new government, but that will be a heavy lift. If successful, the new government will also be right-wing, but possibly less inclined to commit war crimes.
  • Ukraine. Phillips O’Brien points out that new Chief of Staff Stephen Miller is one of the most pro-Putin anti-Ukraine voices in the administration. “Trump is trying to get many of his most terrible priorities, including helping Putin, achieved as soon as possible, to pre-empt the powers of the new Congress.” He also points out that the long-predicted manpower crunch may be hitting — in Russia. Russian casualties rise every month, and are now outrunning recruiting rates.

This week’s developments

This week everybody was talking about the Blue Wave

See the featured post.

I don’t talk about any specific races in that post, but one that gave me particular joy was watching Abdul El-Sayed win the Senate race in Michigan by 7 points. El-Sayed is such an obviously talented communicator. Millions of dollars spent on raising bigotry against him did not get under his skin. He stayed focused on his message: Money out of politics. More money in your pocket. Medicare for All. Even the last-minute betrayal by Haley Stevens (God knows what she was thinking) couldn’t throw him.

And in the end, neither the money nor the bigotry could prevail with Michigan voters.

El-Sayed’s win also blew up a number of myths, including that progressive candidates can’t win in battleground states. It’s true that El-Sayed ran about 4 points behind the Democratic governor candidate Jocelyn Benson, but Benson is a pretty attractive candidate herself, and didn’t face nearly the money-and-bigotry headwinds El-Sayed saw.


Bigotry lost out in a lot of other races too. Keisha Lance Bottoms will be Georgia’s first Black female governor. Deb Haaland is the nation’s first indigenous-peoples governor. Chris Pappas is the first openly gay senator.


I also enjoyed seeing James Talerico and Adam Hamilton win big. These two campaigns might reset how the media covers the relationship between religion and politics, and maybe even how the public thinks about that relationship.

Since Jerry Falwell started the Moral Majority to support Ronald Reagan, “religious” and “conservative” have been almost synonymous. And yes, White Evangelical Christians still went 80-20 for Republicans. But Talerico and Hamilton clearly ran on the liberal Christian message — the message Jesus actually gave in the gospels rather than the message that has been manufactured and put in his mouth more recently. Jesus talked at length about healing the sick, feeding the hungry, and welcoming the stranger, but the gospels don’t bother to record anything he might have said about abortion or homosexuality.

Plenty of conservative ministers described Talerico and Hamilton as “fake Christians”. But I think they’ve got that backwards.


Democracy Defenders Fund’s Norm Eisen takes offense at the WSJ editorial board pooh-poohing the threat Trump posed to the elections.

The reason “Trump didn’t steal the elections” is because we & the pro-voter coalition stopped him EIGHT times over the past 21 months.

and you also might be interested in …

Jobs reports continue to be good. The unemployment rate is 4.1%.


Local communities have been fighting data centers, so corporations may start putting them in places where no one lives: the Great Lakes.

A Microsoft project set up off the coast of northern Scotland in 2018 found that after two years, server failures were reduced by 87% compared with on-land datacenter equivalents. Microsoft executives saw the project, which ended after two years, as an unmitigated success.

Computing throws off heat, so cooling is a constant issue. Underwater data centers, especially in cool climates, all but solve the cooling problem.

However, at some point you start heating up the lake, which changes the eco-system in unpredictable ways. Thinking of Lake Erie as an inexhaustible source of cooling is similar to the way polluting factories used to think of the air or the rivers as nothing more than vehicles for taking pollution “away”, as if “away” never had to be accounted for.


It’s hard to decide which is the worst Musk decision: spending nearly half a billion dollars on losing Republican candidates this year, or Tesla’s Cybertruck, which is ending production as an Edsel-level automotive failure.

Tesla built its Texas lines for a planned capacity of 250,000 trucks a year, and Musk once talked about doubling that.

But the Cybertruck never sold more than 40,000 units in a year, and many of those were internal purchases by SpaceX, another Musk company. So Musk essentially was juicing the numbers by selling Cybertrucks to himself.

Remind me why we’re supposed to believe this guy is a genius.

and let’s close with with a victory lap

On Saturday, the real James “Talifreako” got to interrupt SNL’s Trump imitator during the cold open.

The Blue Wave came. What now?

What happened. My main predictions/observations last week were:

  • The polls look good for Democrats.
  • No pollster can estimate what the last-minute deciders will do, either in terms of who they vote for or whether they vote at all.
  • Probably the last-minute deciders will all do the same thing.

That doesn’t make me Nostradamus, but as far as those predictions went, they look pretty good: The late deciders who voted, voted for Democrats, resulting in a victory far larger than the polls had predicted. I thought one party or the other would take at least 6 of the 7 Senate races that Cook Political Report rated as toss-ups. Not only did the Democrats take 6, but the seventh (Alaska) is leaning their way, and seats that were thought to be leaning Republican in South Carolina and (apparently) Mississippi also flipped. (Expect a final vote total in Mississippi tomorrow. Recounts are not a thing in Mississippi unless a court orders one for a specific reason. Tomorrow is also the day for a final first-round Alaska vote, which will lead to a ranked-choice-voting second round, which shouldn’t take long.) So while Democratic optimists were hoping for 54 Senate seats, 56 is now the most likely outcome.

Just about everybody expected the Democrats to come out with a House majority, but the size of it (259 seats out of 438) is big surprise. Democrats now have 29 of the 50 governorships, and flipped a number of state legislative bodies, including the Texas House.

What it means. There has been a surprising amount of post-election consensus about what this means. Everyone left of Ted Cruz understands that the election was a triumph for Democrats and a disaster for Republicans. The exit polls made the message of the voters clear: They were angry about the cost of living, the war, and the corruption of the Trump regime.

The question is how Democrats should respond. One thing missing from the exit polls is any groundswell of support for specific Democratic programs. Americans are worried about the cost and availability of health insurance, and Medicare-for-All is one way to address that concern, but voters were not specifically asking for it. They want the war to end so that gas prices can come down, but there’s not a widespread call for a war-powers resolution or defunding the forces in the field. They’re upset about corruption, but it’s not obvious that another Trump impeachment would be popular.

Some pundits spin this as “Democrats should be cautious and try to work with Trump as much as they can, rather than antagonize him.” On the other hand, Indian sci-writer Shiv Ramdas observes:

nobody gives you a sweeping mandate like this because they want you to work with the people they just ran tf outta office

I think a more precise interpretation is that the sale is not complete yet. If Democrats are going to address voters’ concerns at all, they’re going to have to do specific things. But all those things will have to be backed by strong messaging that connects the proposal-at-hand to what the American people need and want and asked for. And while some bills may get passed just for the sake of staking out a position (on health care or voting rights, for example), knowing either that Republicans in the Senate will filibuster them or that Trump will veto them, the public also needs to see a few clear accomplishments.

The model here, I think, is the Epstein Files Transparency Act. Trump opposed it, but it was so popular with the American people that some Republicans were willing to back it, and Rep. Thomas Massie was even willing to co-sponsor it. Once it became clear that there would be enough Republican defectors to pass the law, the rest of the party caved. It passed nearly unanimously and Trump signed it. (Then his Justice Department blocked implementing it, which is still playing out in court.)

Another model is the bipartisan housing bill that Congress passed during the summer, which became law even though Trump refused to sign it. Democrats shouldn’t restrict themselves to bills Republicans will support, but finding a few proposals too popular for Republicans to oppose would be a good way to start.

In general, an Epstein/housing path might work like this: A few Republican defectors make a bill likely to pass. If it’s going to pass, more Republicans want to be on the right side of it. If it passes with super-majority support, Trump signs it because he doesn’t want to see his veto overridden.

That path might work for things like raising the minimum wage, an ethics bill to stop members of Congress from trading stocks, repealing some of Trump’s least popular tariffs (like the ones aimed at Canada), universal background checks on gun purchases, and a follow-up Epstein bill that insisted on full release. Restoring Medicaid subsidies might get through this way. Voters were not specifically asking to get aid flowing to Ukraine again and to stop favoring Russia, but Ukraine is more popular than Russia, and a number of Republicans in Congress would defect from Trump on this issue.

Trump might veto all this, but those vetoes would be unpopular. Not a week should pass without Democrats sending to his desk a law that would improve the lives of American workers and families. None of these bills should be show ponies; they should all be things that Democrats genuinely believe in and would be happy to see Trump sign.

I find myself in the unusual position of agreeing with the editorial board of the NYT:

Where can a modern national agenda begin? Picture a parent who can afford a child’s medicine without dread. Picture families who can raise young children without drowning in costs. Picture a generation that can once again own a home. Picture an economy in which those who have prospered most, including the titans of artificial intelligence, help build a bountiful future for everyone else. Every idea Democrats advance should pass three simple tests: Will it work? Will it reach as many Americans as possible? Will people feel it?

This focus avoids a trap that Trump will be eager to spring. For many years, discontent has been brewing in the electorate, because many people believe politicians don’t really care about them. This time, that discontent focused on Republicans, because Trump was obsessed with his golden ballroom while they were deciding which bills they could afford to pay this month. But the discontent itself is non-partisan, and Harris paid its price in 2024. It could turn against Democrats again if the public just sees them scoring political point against Trump while continuing to do nothing that helps ordinary people.

Trump is already gearing up to say: “They don’t care about you. They just want to get Trump.”

Investigations. That’s what makes investigations tricky. The public does care about corruption and wants to see people held accountable for it. But it doesn’t want a lot of finger-pointing that leads to nothing. Trump’s pointless persecution of his enemies, where he has repeatedly had his Justice Department investigate and try to indict people on evidence that can’t get past a grand jury, has increased public skepticism.

So investigations, especially at the beginning, need to quickly expose real crimes or shady deals that should be crimes. There should be no equivalent of the James Comey shells-on-the-beach indictment.

There’s already bipartisan support for a Pete Hegseth impeachment. I would focus on the attacks against fishing boats that Hegseth claims were smuggling drugs, because these are basically murders on the high seas. Wikipedia reports:

As of 27 October 2026, at least 243 people had been killed (including 17 who are missing and presumed dead) in at least 80 strikes on over 81 vessels

A simple analogy makes the point: Imagine a bank had been robbed, and a car was seen speeding away from the bank immediately afterward. Police believe the robbers and the money are in the car. No innocent people are known to be in the car. The car is being tracked and police can easily stop it and arrest the people inside. Instead, they blow it up with a bazooka, killing everyone. Is that how American justice should work?

The 243 dead people from these boats were suspects. Even if they would all turn out to be guilty — and nobody was a hostage or just along for the ride — they deserved their day in court and whatever punishments are set out in laws. Instead, Hegseth had them killed.

Other investigations: Why hasn’t anybody been held to account for the murders of Renee Good, Alex Pretti, or Lorenzo Salgado Araujo by ICE agents? How did companies associated with Eric Trump and Don Jr. get so many government contracts? How much taxpayer money got spent on partisan ads like the “public service announcements” lauding President Trump? What are conditions like in those ICE detention camps?

Overreach? A lot of the national-media center-right punditry is wringing its hands over the idea that Democrats might actually try to do something with their new majorities. The same people who thought Trump’s 49.8% vote total in 2024 gave him a mandate to do whatever crazy thing came into his head are now worried that Democrats’ 56%-43% victory will lead to hubris.

But the problem, as I see it, isn’t that Democrats will try to do too much but that they will try to do too little. The New Republic’s Michael Tomasky makes a very good point:

The intra-Democratic debate that I despise above all others is the one that holds that Democrats must either do X or Y but cannot possibly do both X and Y. It has made me insane for years. … Think of it this way. Have you ever, once in your life, heard conservatives and Republicans engage in an argument like: Well, we can cut taxes, or we can prosecute the culture wars, but we surely can’t do both! I hope you’re laughing, because the idea is laughable on its face.

Obama had ten months of filibuster-proof majorities in Congress, and what he got out of it was the Affordable Care Act. That was his top priority, so he thought it eliminated doing anything else. It was a wasted opportunity.

Overreachy things like Medicare-for-All or a Trump impeachment are only a problem if they crowd out achievable smaller things like raising the minimum wage or keeping rural hospitals open.

Trump’s likely response. If you watched the 60 Minutes interview that aired yesterday, you may have been encouraged. Trump sounded conciliatory, and talked about working with Democrats on a number of issues, including immigration. But between the interview itself and its air date, he appointed Stephen Miller his new chief of staff.

Miller is one of the most polarising figures in the administration and one of Trump’s closest and longest-serving advisers, having joined his 2016 presidential campaign as a speechwriter. He is a former aide to the former senator Jeff Sessions of Alabama, who would go on to serve as Trump’s first attorney general. In Trump’s first term, Miller was the driving force behind policies such as family separation and a travel ban on Muslim-majority countries. More than a hundred Democrats in Congress signed a letter to Trump calling Miller a “documented white nationalist” and demanding his removal.

Chris Hayes commented:

If you were thinking: what could Trump do to push his approval rating down even further and open up the possibility of a 1964/1980/2008 style victory for Dems in 2028? The answer is: put Stephen Miller in charge of everything. And guess what?

My personal reaction: I want Stephen Miller in front of TV cameras as much as possible. His physical presence makes his message sound just as creepy as it actually is.

Here’s the headline in Le Monde, a leading French publication: “Stephen Miller, reactionary ideologue and white supremacist, promoted head of Trump administration“. Contrast that direct truth-telling with this fascist-friendly characterization in the NYT:

Mr. Miller has been the driver of the president’s most muscular actions, including the use of increasingly hostile tactics to capture immigrants across the country and the bombing of small boats in the Caribbean Sea and the eastern Pacific Ocean that he and Mr. Trump declared constituted a foreign invasion.

Apparently “muscular” is a new synonym for “criminal”.

And one more thing. Black turnout was up, particularly in the South. But we should not conclude from that fact that Republican attempts to suppress the Black vote were harmless. Apparently, Black citizens felt so strongly about this election — partly because of the suppression efforts — that they overcame the obstacles that were put in their way. But the obstacles still exist, and in less motivating elections they will make a difference.

“So much of what this administration has done has been to roll back the protections that give us access to the ballot, while simultaneously flooding us with propaganda that tells us that it doesn’t matter,” said Nadine Smith, president and CEO of Color of Change, which worked to mobilize voters across the south before the election. “What you saw was Black voters showing up in the face of an administration that has spent two years attacking our rights, weakening voter protections and redrawing maps specifically to diminish Black political power.

This is just one example of the many ways Trump tried to cheat, but came up short. I haven’t seen a clear what-if-we-had-used-the-old-maps assessment of the US House races, but Trump’s push to gerrymander did not gain all the seats he thought it would, and the redistricting war he started may have been won by the Democrats, whose gerrymanders were fewer but more successful.

The courts blocked Trump’s attempts to set aside ballots that his Justice Department claimed (probably falsely) were being cast by non-citizens. His efforts to turn Alaska’s two-Dan-Sullivans ballot into a criminal case has fallen flat, because no one can name the law it supposedly violates. (I can’t remember who said it, but my favorite assessment is: “If confusing voters is a crime, all politicians should be in jail.”) Trump’s claim that all votes for the “other” Dan Sullivan should be counted for the incumbent senator also goes nowhere, because in Alaska’s ranked-choice-voting system, voters have already said where they want their votes to go if their first candidate can’t win. Trump may claim to know their intentions, but they have already stated their intentions in a legally binding way.

But just because Trump failed to cheat this time doesn’t mean we should ignore the effort. This is part of a general pattern where Trump wants to be treated like a five-year-old, whose cheating attempts can be laughed off because he’s so bad at it. But those politically and racially gerrymandered districts are still standing, waiting for future elections. The myth of non-citizen voters is still widely believed by MAGA cultists. The restrictions on early voting and mail-in voting continue, along with the closing of polling places convenient for non-White voters. The corrupt Justice Department is still in office. The Supreme Court’s dismantling of the Voting Rights Act is a done deal.

It didn’t work this time, but there’s still a lot to clean up before we can have truly fair elections.

The Monday Morning Teaser

On a typical Monday morning, I write the Teaser to let you know what I’ve been thinking about this week, and what you’ll see in the posts that will appear later. That seems unnecessary this week, because I’ve been thinking about the same thing the rest of you have: the Democrats’ huge win on Tuesday and what they should do with quantity of power they’ve managed to claw back from Trump. Sure, there were a couple of other things that happened this week, like Netanyahu’s challenger being given the first shot at organizing a new government in Israel, but mainly all eyes have been on American politics: how big the win will turn out to be, what Democrats will do next, how Trump will respond, and so on.

So the featured article will be called “The Blue Wave came. What now?” I’ll try to get it out by 10 EST, but it has a lot to cover, so it might slip.

The weekly summary will probably be fairly short this week, because I haven’t had a lot of attention to give to the rest of the world. I’ll try to get that out by noon.

Peace, someday

Peace will come someday, but not from cutting support for Ukraine. The war will end when Putin gives up his dream of absorbing Ukraine into Russia, when he understands that he cannot win.

– Anne Applebaum

This week’s featured post is “Your 2026 election-watching guide“.

Ongoing stories

  • Trump’s assault on American democracy. Trump has tried to interfere in the midterms in a variety of ways, most of which the courts have beaten back. His outrageous lawsuit to prevent Alaska from certifying its Senate race if Trump’s candidate loses got thrown out, though it may reappear after the election. The attempt to get states to put aside ballots from people Trump claims (on flimsy grounds) are not citizens has also not succeeded. Expect shenanigans to continue, and hope the courts are up to the challenge.
  • Climate change. Natural gas is often touted as being better for the environment than other fossil fuels like coal. But that’s only if methane doesn’t leak during the drilling and transportation process. The Biden administration increased controls on methane, but Trump is rolling those rules back.
  • Gaza. The Gaza genocide seems not to have had much traction as an issue in Israel’s recent election.
  • Ukraine. Over the last few weeks, Trump has largely dropped the pretense that his administration is either an ally of Ukraine or a neutral arbiter seeking peace. The “deal” he keeps pushing Ukraine to accept is to surrender territory to its invader. More below.

This week’s developments

This week’s biggest story is tomorrow’s election

The featured post is a watch guide if you plan to spend Tuesday night in front of a television, as I do. Apparently most of my friends consider this a form of torture, so my envisioned watch party isn’t happening. Maybe you’ll have more luck.


Trump has been holding rallies in all the red states that threaten to defect from his coalition, and he is getting increasingly unhinged. The American public is like the frog that doesn’t realize it’s slowly being boiled: We’ve watched Trump’s mental deterioration happen gradually, so it doesn’t shock us the way it should. He tells the story of a simple dementia test where he repeated back five words they gave him, and claims doctors were wowed that he could do it. “Almost no one can do it. But I can because I’m a freaking genius.”

But if you watch any significant chunk of his speeches, read the increasingly bizarre rants he posts on Truth Social, or listen to his ridiculous self-aggrandizing fantasies (“I would have won the Vietnam War in a week.” He would have won the Afghan War in three weeks — ignoring the fact that he had troops in Afghanistan for his entire first term and didn’t win.), it’s obvious that this man is insane. J. D. Vance should be asked every day why he doesn’t invoke the 25th Amendment.


In his blog The Farce, Jason Sattler offers a message for any of his fellow Jews who happen to live in Michigan: Religious bigotry, even if it takes the form of Islamophobia, will eventually hurt Jews. He asks them to reject Mike Rogers’ campaign of hate and vote for Abdul El-Sayed.

We know that Islamophobia feeds the same beast as Jew hatred for the same cruel, senseless aims. We know this even as our community struggles to come to terms with even how to discuss the horrors of October 7 and the war crimes that followed. And we know this tidal wave of hate is only coming because Mike Rogers can’t run on anything else.


Corruption is a big issue in this campaign, but it should be bigger. Trump’s net worth has more than doubled since he started his second term, and that doesn’t count how much his sons and son-in-law have made.


Elon Musk has spent over $440 million this year trying to buy a Republican Congress, nearly $35 million on Ken Paxton alone. He is clearly afraid of being subpoenaed by Democrat-led congressional committees to explain things like temporarily cutting off Ukraine’s access to Starlink for its high-speed drones, or being called to account for the deaths his destruction of USAID is causing, or whatever happened to all the sensitive government data DOGE sucked up.

Musk responded to these possibilities with threats:

Those who pick fights with me should understand that I will find out who is really pulling the strings and come for them, not just their puppets.

One look at that tweet tells me everything I need to know: Musk has too much power. Concentrating that much power in one unelected individual is a threat to the Republic.

and Ukraine/Russia

You can’t say you weren’t warned. Back in the 2016 presidential debates, Hillary Clinton predicted that Trump would be “Putin’s puppet” and spelled out what that meant.

It’s pretty clear you won’t admit that the Russians have engaged in cyberattacks against the United States of America, that you encouraged espionage against our people, that you are willing to spout the Putin line, sign up for his wish list, break up NATO, do whatever he wants to do, and that you continue to get help from him, because he has a very clear favorite in this race.

In his first administration, Trump tried repeatedly to undo the sanctions that the Obama administration had placed against Russia after its annexation of Crimea. But his administration and the Republican caucuses in Congress were full of people who respected the Russia threat and stood in his way. He also sided with Putin’s claims against the conclusions of the US intelligence agencies.

By the time Trump took office for the second time, in January 2025, Putin’s invasion of the rest of Ukraine was nearly three years old. During the 2024 campaign, Trump often said he could end the war in 24 hours; once in power, it was clear how he thought the war should end: Ukraine should surrender and give Putin all the territory he had demanded. (“Crimea, Luhansk and Donetsk will be recognized as de facto Russian”.) That is still his position.

The Biden administration had provided something like $200 billion in military aid to Ukraine — one of its few actions that had bipartisan support in Congress. Trump began scaling that back soon after he took office, and by August of 2025 had cut US support to zero, though the US would continue to sell weapons to its NATO allies, which they would pass on to Kiev. Republicans in Congress, like the late Senator Lindsey Graham, continued to understand that Putin was the bad guy in this situation, so in August they passed the Graham Act giving Trump the power to sanction countries that buy Russia oil.

Trump signed that act, and then — surprise! — made a deal for the US to buy Russian diesel itself. Just before the Graham Act was scheduled to take effect, Trump waived all its anti-Russia sanctions.

Although the deal is unlikely to lower diesel prices, it will benefit Putin and Russia. Diesel sales will generate revenue that could be used to prolong the war in Ukraine. Since announcing the deal, Trump has also told Ukraine to stop attacking Russian refineries.

And Trump became more explicit about blaming Ukraine for its failure to surrender to Russia.

I suggest they get a new leader who can make a deal because [Zelensky] could have made many deals and for some reason he never does.

At around this same time, Ukraine’s high-speed drones lost access to Elon Musk’s Starlink/Starshield system, crippling its battlefield operations. Though access was eventually restored, this may have been a shot-across-the-bow warning Ukraine that it had better surrender to Russia.

Support for Ukraine continues to be popular in both parties. But after the midterms are over, Trump may decide he no longer cares what voters think. The master will pull his strings, and even a new Democratic Congress may not be able to interfere.

Phillips O’Brien notes:

This Summer and Fall have seen a noticeable and continuing increase in the number of Ukrainian civilians being deliberately targeted and killed by Russian bombing. It is becoming more and more common to have mass casualty events on a weekly basis, and Russian ranged systems are being used to hunt out trains, buses, apartment buildings, etc. … While we await the grim figure for Ukrainian civilian casualties for October 2026 as a whole, it is clear that 2026 is shaping up to be the worst year for Ukrainian civilian deaths caused by the Russian military since 2022, the year of Russian full-scale invasion. … This slaughter is a result of Russia’s strategic decision. It is an attempt to break Ukrainian will by killing non-combatants. It is also a primal scream of rage at the Ukrainian people for not bowing down in front of the Russian military and Vladimir Putin.

He further points out how Trump continues to placate the pro-Ukraine Congress and American people by making phony announcements of support. On October 30, for the benefit of the midterm electorate, the State Department announced that 500 of the most advanced Patriot missiles would be sold (not given) to Ukraine — for delivery in 2030 at the earliest.

and demonstrations in Europe

I was in Paris on my honeymoon when the demonstrations started there. I got emails from home asking if we were OK.

If you’ve ever been in a city where “riots” are going on, you probably understand how localized such disturbances can be. In the vast majority of the city life goes on normally. That certainly was our experience of Paris, though I gather that things got worse after we left. (Fortunately, we were able to visit the Louvre twice before it temporarily shut down.)

On the way back to our hotel one evening, we happened on a demonstration outside some public building. Neither of us speaks or reads French in any but the most rudimentary way, so the slogans being chanted were hard to make out. The signs seemed to be about children and perhaps homelessness. Later we read that there had been demonstrations against sexual abuse in the schools, so maybe that was one of them. There was no violence and we walked through the center of the demonstration with no sense of danger. The demonstrators we saw were trying to communicate with the larger public, not terrorize it. Later we figured out that on a previous day in a different neighborhood we had walked past one of the shops that burned

Trump and various online provocateurs tried to convince their American audience that this had something to do with immigration.

“The migrants have taken over France,” the president posted on Truth Social. “They must CLOSE THE BORDERS, FAST!”

This appears to be pure opportunism on Trump’s part. French President Macron denounced “stupid” comments by foreign leaders, presumably meaning Trump and Israel’s Netanyahu.

By most accounts, the demonstrations began with a student movement protesting against poor funding for schools, especially high schools. They then spread to a general sense of pessimism about young people’s prospects in France, and then to a larger movement of citizens concerned about the high cost of living, largely spurred by the increased fuel prices caused by Trump’s war.

None of these concerns should seem foreign to Americans. We just don’t have the same mass protest traditions the French do.

Another factor that Americans should be able to identify with: There’s no money to satisfy the demonstrators’ demands. France is running persistently high budget deficits, and the country faces increased needs in many areas. For example, the sudden unreliability of America’s commitment to NATO puts pressure on all European countries to increase their defense spending. And the nation’s difficult fiscal situation pushes investors to seek higher interest rates, making the fiscal situation even worse.

The main difference here is that the US runs its deficit in dollars, which its Federal Reserve can create at will. France owes euros, which are controlled by the European Central Bank. That gives the US more short-term flexibility, but it’s not clear that our long term situation is any better. For example, in the recently concluded FY 2026, we ran a $2 trillion deficit. We got essentially nothing for that money: We didn’t make some major national investment, spend our way out of recession, fight a major war, or deal with some external challenge like the Covid pandemic. Subtract the estimated $47 billion spent on attacking Iran, and it’s still a huge deficit. And that’s just business as usual.

and elections in Brazil, Israel, and Serbia

Brazil’s election was a very pleasant surprise. Jair Bolsonaro was Brazil’s Trump. When he lost his reelection bid in 2022, he reacted as Trump had in 2021:

On 8 January 2023, his supporters attacked the buildings of the Supreme Court of Brazil, the National Congress, and the Planalto Presidential Palace to instigate a military coup d’état and reinstate Bolsonaro as president.

Because the Brazilian justice system is less corrupt than ours, Bolsonaro was tried and convicted. He is currently in prison. His sone Flavio ran for president in Brazil’s recent election and led after the first round, in which neither he nor incumbent president Lula got a majority. It was widely expected Bolsonaro would win, and would pardon his father just as Trump pardoned all the January 6 criminals in the US.

But instead, Lula won the runoff in a surprise victory. Flavio was ordered to surrender his passport, pending an investigation into a money-laundering scheme. The Trump administration then conspired to spirit him to Florida, where he is expected to set up a government-in-exile.

Remember how upset Trump usually gets about South American countries sending their criminals here?


Serbia’s strong-man Aleksandar Vučić also fell after 12 years in power. He appears to be accepting his defeat. His enablers are backing down.

Serbia’s public broadcaster RTV Vojvodina has publicly apologized to viewers for years of one-sided coverage. The statement came after Aleksandar Vucic, who ran for prime minister, lost Sunday’s election in Serbia to the student movement. “Public broadcasting has failed to do its job for many years. A lot was left unsaid, a lot was overlooked, information was presented one-sidedly, reporting was uncritical, and the right questions were not asked, or no questions at all. And for that we must apologize to our viewers,” said Eror, as quoted by the TV channel N1.


It’s hard to know what to make of Israel’s elections held last Tuesday. These were the first elections held since the October 7, 2023. Prime Minister Netanyahu’s Likud Party lost seats in the Knesset, but remains the largest party. AP reports:

Netanyahu’s coalition, made up of ultranationalist and ultra-Orthodox parties, supported strengthening Israel’s Jewish character. It pushed for more settlement construction in the occupied West Bank and allowed for military draft exemptions for ultra-Orthodox Jews. It also attempted to push through an overhaul of the country’s judiciary in 2023 that drew mass protests.

Eisenkot’s camp promoted a vision where Israel’s Jewish character lives in harmony with its liberal democratic ideals. It promised honest leadership and accountability for Israel’s Oct. 7 failures, vowed to bolster the judiciary and end the military draft exemptions. They also promised to fix Israel’s international standing, which has deteriorated because of the Gaza war and settler violence in the West Bank.

Neither party seems likely to put together a 61-seat Knesset majority without making deal with the Arab parties, which hold 19 seats. The Arabs would never partner with Netanyahu, but Eisenkot has also pledged not to deal with them.

If no one can form a majority, they’ll have to hold the elections again.

and you also might be interested in …

Chances are, you’ve eaten more than your usual quota of chocolate this last week. And maybe you got nostalgic about how good chocolate used to taste back when you were the trick-or-treater collecting candy rather than the homebody handing it out.

Well, apparently it’s not just your imagination. New York magazine writer Rachel Handler did a deep dive into how chocolate is made, who makes it, and why it (like just about everything else at this stage of capitalism) is getting enshittified.


It was a sad week for Star Trek fans. Walter Koenig, who played Chekov in the original series, died at the age of 90. And then Wednesday, Patrick Stewart died.

Stewart’s Captain Picard wasn’t just a beloved character, he represented a new direction, emphasizing exploration and negotiation rather than the more warlike virtues of Captain Kirk. It took a great actor to pull that off, and Stewart was one.


Under Trump, the US is getting a reputation as a country hostile to foreigners, and it’s killing our tourism industry.


The Justice Department’s latest attempt to keep the Hunter Biden case going just failed: The case against two FBI agents that DoJ said lied to Congress about Hunter’s laptop was dismissed.

A federal judge on Monday dismissed a criminal complaint against two former FBI officials accused of making false statements to Congress about Hunter Biden, saying the investigation that produced the charges was rushed, overtly political and dogged by “critical mistakes.”

“What has transpired here cannot be described as anything other than weaponization,” U.S. Magistrate Judge Zia Faruqui said in a scathing ruling from the bench that dismissed the case against former officials Nikki Floris and Bradley Benavides.

and let’s close with something scary

The Onion has become one of the most accurate sources of journalism in the country: “ICE Agent, 7-Year-Old Both Wearing Same ‘Military Commando’ Halloween Costume“.

Your 2026 election-watching guide

What polls and experts expect to happen. Real Clear Politics’ generic congressional ballot polling average has Democrats up 8.9% (52.0%-43.1%), and that margin has been in the 8-9% range for about a month. Such a lead is consistent with a wave election big enough that gerrymandering the districts shouldn’t matter. So just about everybody expects Democrats to win the House.

Things get interesting in the Senate, where 34 Democrats and 31 Republicans are not up for election this year. Cooks Political Report lists 9 Democrats and 11 Republicans as solid favorites, bringing the totals to 43 Democrats and 42 Republicans. Each party has two seats listed as “likely” and two more as “leaning” in their favor. So if you add those in, it’s 47-46 for the Democrats. That leaves 7 toss-up races, which is an unusually large number. So any outcome between a 54-46 Democratic majority and a 53-47 Republican majority (the same distribution we have now) is plausible. (Democrats have had fantasies about flipping seats in Mississippi and Florida, but that seems like a bridge too far.)

How that happened is fascinating. For months, Cooks has been shifting races towards the Democrats, but not across the board: Races might go from “likely Republican” and “leaning Republican” to “toss-up”, but the toss-up races would not shift to “likely” or “leaning” Democratic. (The NYT/Siena poll does seem to show Dems pulling away, but it could be an outlier.)

That appears to have happened for a few reasons: The worst impacts of Trump’s policies — high diesel prices, closing hospitals, data-center construction — have tended to fall in rural states that usually vote Republican: Iowa, Kansas, Nebraska, South Carolina, Alaska. Because these states weren’t supposed to be competitive, the GOP is stuck with some poorly chosen candidates. I mean, Roger Marshall is a sucky senator, but it’s Kansas, so who cares? Darlene Graham isn’t her late brother Lindsey, but it’s South Carolina, so anybody with an R next to her name was supposed to be safe.

Meanwhile in blue states like Michigan and Maine, Democrats have maintained small but fairly stable leads in the polls. In a shifting national environment, you’d expect them to start pulling away, but they haven’t. So the RCP average has Troy Jackson up 3.3% on Susan Collins in Maine, and Abdul El-Sayed up 5.3% in Michigan. Both margins were considerably smaller before averaging in yesterday’s NYT/Siena poll.

You especially can’t count on small margins in a mid-term election, because mid-terms are all about turnout. The difference between Obama’s landslide in 2008 and the Democrats’ “shellacking” in 2010 wasn’t so much that people changed their minds. It was that the 2008 Obama coalition of young voters and minorities didn’t come out to vote in 2010. 2010 was an older, whiter electorate, and it elected a way more conservative Congress.

So a big piece of the Blue Wave theory is that Democrats are more motivated this year than Republicans. Trump voters who believed he would lower prices, end foreign wars, and generally look out for the little guy (at least the White male little guys) are disillusioned and unmotivated. But Democrats who have watched Trump circumvent laws, enrich himself, and send his ICE thugs out to murder American citizens with no consequences — they’re motivated.

And that explains the Republicans’ closing arguments that center on fear and bigotry: Democrats will turn America Communist, let brown people run the country, change your child’s gender, take away your guns, and persecute Christians. El-Sayed is a jihadist, James Talerico and Adam Hamilton are fake Christians, and so on. Those arguments won’t convince anybody who cares about the price of gas or health care, but they’re not supposed to. They’re supposed to fire up the MAGA cultists to go out and vote.

The upshot of all this, in my opinion, is that the toss-up races will almost all go the same way. One party or the other will sweep at least six of the seven. The people who make up their minds at the last minute, the people who may or may not vote — they’re all going to do the same thing. I just can’t tell you what it is.

Last-minute events. The Michigan Senate race got roiled Sunday when Rep. Haley Stevens (who lost to Abdul El-Sayed in the primary) withdrew her endorsement of El-Sayed and made an appearance with Republican nominee Mike Rogers, whom she had previously described as “a rubber stamp for Donald Trump“. In a subsequent interview with CNN’s Anderson Cooper, she dodged and flailed when asked what changed her mind. Even as her social media message absurdly accused El-Sayed of campaigning on “hate”, she appealed to Islamophobia by referring to him only as “Abdul”.

Michigan observers question how much difference this will make. It has been a much bigger story in the national media than locally, and has focused attention more on Stevens herself than on any problem with El-Sayed’s candidacy. Her career as a Democrat is over now, and it’s hard to imagine her as a Republican given her record in Congress. Possibly she’s hoping for a job as a lobbyist with AIPAC, who channeled $30 million into her primary campaign and has also spent millions to support Rogers.

Similarly, the would-be scandal of Democrats recruiting a second Dan Sullivan to run for the Senate in Alaska seems to be more of a national-media story than an issue on the ground in Alaska. The media-criticism blog Finding Gravity comments:

[T]he national news media is doing everything they can to make the central story of the last days of this election season an alleged political maneuver by Alaska Democrats that was, by all accounts, legal, consistent with past behavior by both major political parties, and unlikely to have any real effect on the outcome of the Alaska Senate race. America’s dominant news companies, led by the New York Times, have literally ignored the new rape allegation against the president of the United States while breathlessly hyping the Alaska maneuver, giving Donald Trump the distraction he desperately seeks and a phony premise for his anti-democratic efforts to effectively cancel a Senate election that could determine control of the entire U.S. Senate.

… At this writing, the New York Times has now run more than a dozen reports on this matter in just three days. The Times is in the kind of full-court press mode it saves for things like Joe Biden stumbling over his words. By my tally, the alleged Peltola maneuver has been a primary subject of six New York Times articles, four New York Times newsletters, a New York Times podcast, a New York Times video, and two letters to the editor the New York Times chose to run. At least nine New York Times journalists have bylines on these pieces. I can only imagine what the Sunday crossword puzzle has in store for us.

I have two observations:

  • If Republicans had done something like this, it would be covered as an infuriating-but-clever move to own the libs.
  • It’s a non-story, because Alaska has instant run-off voting. Even if you get confused about which Dan Sullivan is the Republican incumbent, despite the words “Republican” and “incumbent” appearing next to one Dan Sullivan’s name, you just rank the two next to each other. When the “fake” Dan Sullivan is eliminated, your vote will flow to the “real” one. So there is absolutely no chance this maneuver will affect the outcome of the election.

How the night unfolds. There’s a certain amount of tea-leaf reading you can do before any polls close. Exit polling goes on all day. The major media networks are committed not to release any of that information while the polls are open, but their talking heads have probably seen it. They’re generally pretty careful not to reveal anything directly, but I believe they shade their predictions so that they don’t look stupid later. So if MS-NOW folks are still talking about the Blue Wave at 5 p.m., it’s probably still plausible. Likewise, if Fox News pundits are making not-so-fast noises, that could be what the exit polls are showing.

The returns start coming in at 7 p.m. EST, when the polls close in Georgia, Indiana, Kentucky, South Carolina, Virginia, Vermont. (All poll closing times and a summary of the interesting races are in this NPR article. Some eastern time zone districts in Kentucky and Indiana will report at 6.) None of the toss-up Senate races are here, but you can get some insight into how the night will go by looking at margins. The South Carolina Senate race is supposed to go to Republican Darlene Graham by a small margin. How small? If this race stays too close to call for a long time, it’s a good night for the Democrats. If Graham wins with surprising ease, that’s good for Republicans. The WaPo’s Henry Olsen targets five points as the line to watch.

The Georgia governor’s race is also expected to be close.

Florida’s eastern time zone polls close. A number of House races are close, including some recently gerrymandered districts.

At 7:30: North Carolina, Ohio, West Virginia. The big race here is the Ohio Senate race, where Democrat Sherrod Brown has a small lead in the polls, but the race is considered a toss-up. Don’t expect that to get called early either way. The thing I’ll be watching for early is Black turnout in Cleveland and other big cities. The first bad sign for Hillary Clinton in 2016 was low Black turnout in Cleveland. Probably the Democratic early vote comes in first, so Brown should have a big early lead that shrinks as the night goes on.

Roy Cooper is expected to flip the North Carolina Senate seat to the Democrats. Polls have him up double digits. If that holds, and the race gets called early, that’s a sign that the polls are accurate. NC-1 is a toss-up House seat. Gerrymandering was supposed to push Democrat Don Davis out of Congress. If it doesn’t, that’s a bad sign for Republican gerrymanders across the country.

OH-7 is another toss-up race. This time Republican Max Miller is the incumbent.

At 8: Alabama, Connecticut, Delaware, Florida, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Mississippi, Missouri, New Hampshire, New Jersey, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Tennessee, Washington, D.C.

The Maine Senate race is one of the closest in the country. Chris Pappas is supposed to be ahead in New Hampshire; if he’s not, that’s a bad sign for Democrats. If the Mississippi Senate race is close, then the toss-up races are trending Democratic.

In Pennsylvania the focus is on House seats, where Democrats are expected to flip several. Florida is another test of Republican gerrymandering.

Josh Shapiro and Jay Pritzker will easily get reelected as governors in Pennsylvania and Illinois, but the margins matter if you think of them as a presidential contenders in 2028.

Somewhere in the 8-9 range, expect to hear projections that Democrats will take the House. The majority of races won’t be called, but enough toss-up races should come in to determine the outcome.

8:30. Arkansas. The only real news here will be if the Republicans don’t sweep.

9: Arizona, Colorado, Iowa, Kansas, Louisiana, Michigan, Minnesota, Nebraska, New Mexico, New York, North Dakota, South Dakota, Texas, Wisconsin and Wyoming

Lots to chew on here. Michigan is a toss-up Senate race with last-minute events. Cook has the Iowa Senate race as a toss-up and the polls are very close, but I have a hard time believing Iowans won’t come home to the Republicans.

Texas and Kansas test the liberal Christian message. Will Christian voters stick with MAGA, or do the teachings of Jesus still mean something? Will Christian voters prioritize anti-abortion and anti-gay rights (two issues Jesus never mentioned) or helping the poor, healing the sick, and welcoming the stranger (which he talked about all the time)?

NPR says this about Texas:

Talarico could take an early lead as early voting data and mail in ballots are counted but Paxton will probably start to gain ground as counties will start reporting their totals. While the governor’s race between Republican Gov. Greg Abbott and state Rep. Gina Hinojosa is also close, Abbott is still favored.

New York has some Republican House seats that Democrats need to flip.

By now, you shouldn’t be looking for tea leaves to read any more. The night will have developed momentum one way or the other.

10: Montana, Nevada, Utah. Not a lot of excitement here. Mostly watch for close races from earlier states to begin resolving.

11: California, Idaho, Oregon, Washington. No major Senate races. California is a test of Democratic gerrymandering. But California results take a long time to come in, so we may not know much until Wednesday, if then. Ditto for California ballot questions, like the wealth tax.

12: Hawaii.

1: Alaska. If the Senate is close nationally, it could all come down to Alaska. Put some coffee on.

The Monday Morning Teaser

I’m back. The wedding itself was everything we hoped it would be (thanks for asking), and France and Spain made for a lovely honeymoon. By chance, we were always about two days ahead of the major demonstrations and unrest, and three days ahead of the train crash on the Madrid-Seville rail line. So we did a lot of looking at the news and saying: “Didn’t we walk past that shop?”

My nominee for the most beautiful cathedral in the world is La Sagrada Familia in Barcelona, where the afternoon light streams in like this:

Anyway, it’s election eve. All month, polls and pundits have been trending toward the Democrats, with the result that the once impossible — Democratic control of the Senate — is now being predicted more often than not. Trump has been unable to turn the tide for a reason I predicted before I left: He has no positive message other than denial of reality — the economy is wonderful, prices are going down, and the war is all but won.

That has left Republicans with nothing to run on other than fear: Democrats are communists and jihadists who will take away your guns, sex-change your children, and outlaw eating meat, while Republicans are manly men with great butts. That message shouldn’t work with people who are worried about affording gas or health care, and (if you believe the polls) it hasn’t.

But should we believe the polls? I mean, can a Democrat really win a Senate seat in Kansas or Texas? We’ll see tomorrow night.

Today, I’m going to put out a returns-watching guide, setting the stage with pollsters predictions and then looking hour-by-hour at what returns will best tell the story. I’m hoping to get that out by 10 EST.

The summary post actually has more than a month to cover, so I’ll center on a few big things: Trump’s ever-more-open support of Putin’s invasion of Ukraine, the demonstrations in France, and the elections in Brazil, Serbia, and Israel. I hope to get that out by noon.