
Is new leadership worth the turmoil? And what should any leaders try to do?
The Democratic House and Senate minority leaders — Hakeem Jeffries and Chuck Schumer — are in line to become Speaker and Majority Leader once the new Democratic majorities take their seats in January. Unfortunately, they are two of the least popular figures in Washington. According the RCP polling averages, Jeffries’ approval rating is 11 points underwater (28% favorable, 39% unfavorable) while Schumer’s is even worse: 25% favorable and 49% unfavorable, for a net of -24%.
So ever since the midterm blue wave, Democrats have been debating: Can we do better? There are a few reasons not to ask this question:
- You don’t fire your leadership after a big win.
- A leadership battle allows the media to fire up the “Democrats is disarray” theme they love so much. Similarly: This is an inside-baseball story that distracts from Trump regime corruption, the war, the bad economy, and all the other favorable developments happening in the outside world
- Leadership in Congress isn’t primarily about being popular or striking a charismatic figure on TV. Most of the action is behind the scenes: counting votes and figuring out what you can unite your caucus behind. Let the caucuses themselves decide who will do this best.
All those points are debatable. Schumer, in particular, has only a middling claim on the midterm success, which seems likely to net the Democrats a totally unexpected 56-44 majority. (The last two seats are just about decided. Scott Colum was declared the winner in Mississippi on Wednesday, while in Alaska Mary Peltola is right on the edge of a 50% total. She will either go over that total and win without calculating the instant-runoff, or will go into that runoff needing hardly any new votes. She might go over the top just because of the voters who didn’t name a second choice at all — that would change the number of total votes and maybe put her first-round total over 50%. Senator Fetterman is making noises about leaving the party, but no one cares.) Schumer gets some credit for recruiting good candidates, but he also recruited clunkers like Janet Mills in Maine and Haley Stevens in Michigan. He didn’t put money behind either Scott Colum in Mississippi (who narrowly won) or Angie Nixon in Florida (who narrowly lost), but few predicted either of those races would be close enough for some extra funding to matter.
The lack of a leadership battle will bring its own round of bad press, something like “You voted for change, but Democrats aren’t listening.”
I have some sympathy for the third point. Nancy Pelosi also wasn’t popular with progressive Democrats, but she was arguably the most effective speaker of my lifetime. Pelosi saw herself as the shepherd of an unruly flock, which she managed to keep together remarkably well. Just because you’re the leader doesn’t mean anyone will necessarily follow you, something a string of ineffective Republican speakers have made clear.
Still, the inside-baseball view of congressional leadership is maybe a step or two behind the times. In the absence of an incumbent President or clear front-runner for the presidency, the Party desperately needs a national spokesperson. Like it or not, Schumer and Jeffries will wind up in that role, and neither is suited for it. On the other hand, as fun as it would be to have someone as telegenic as AOC laying out an inspiring agenda … if she can’t unite the caucus behind it enough to get bills passed, what’s the point? Ideally you need both a vote-counting shepherd and a telegenic talking head on TV.
At the moment, no one has emerged to challenge Jeffries for the speakership. (To be honest, I don’t like the optics of staging a coup just before the first Black speaker is about to ascend.) But Senator Chris Van Hollen of Maryland is challenging Schumer for the majority leader job.
So who is this guy? Van Hollen has been in the Senate since 2017, in Congress since 2003, and in elected office since 1991. He’s 67 years old to Schumer’s 76-later-this-month. So this not “generational change” in any significant sense. He seems more progressive than Schumer, but is far from a firebrand. He started making a case for Medicare for All about a year ago. He called attention to the regime’s foreign-prison policy by flying to El Salvador to meet with Maryland resident Kilmar Abrego Garcia in the CECOT prison where Trump had illegally sent him.
Bernie Sanders wrote an op-ed endorsing him.
This is not a personality contest. This is a debate about the future of the Democratic party. It is a debate about whether the Democratic party remains a top-down party dominated by billionaire campaign contributors, inside-the-beltway consultants and 30-second TV ads, or whether we can transform it into a grassroots party of, by and for the working families of our country.
But it’s not clear how much of Bernie’s agenda Van Hollen actually shares. He is a critic of the Israeli government.
He has accused Israel of committing genocide in Gaza. Van Hollen has called for restrictions on U.S. military aid to Israel and worked to halt arms shipments to Israel. Israel has repeatedly denied accusations of genocide. Meanwhile, Schumer, who has led Senate Democrats since 2017, has a long history of support for Israel. He remains one of Washington’s most-prominent defenders of the U.S.-Israel relationship even as he has criticized Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s handling of the war in Gaza.
So there are differences between him and Schumer, but I don’t see Van Hollen as revolutionary, if that’s what you’re looking for.
Josh Marshall makes a worthwhile point: Changing Senate leadership is far less important than ending the filibuster, which neither Sanders nor Van Hollen have endorsed.
One TPM reader just told me it’s crazy to get into a big fight about this now when President Trump’s veto makes this mostly moot. That is a credible argument; but I disagree. With the filibuster in place, you’re not going to be able to pass a bunch of popular bills that President Trump is forced to veto. And you’re not going to be able to put Senate Republicans on the spot and force them to vote against popular bills either. So a lot of what people want Democrats to do out of the gate next year isn’t actually going to happen. It’ll peter out in parliamentary minutiae. … As long as the Democratic caucus is an amorphous blob when it comes to the filibuster, sort of against it but not in a specific or definitive way, it’s impossible to grab on to, impossible to start dividing the caucus into supporters and opponents and begin pressuring or convincing members to shift from one column to the other.If you’re serious about ending the filibuster — and almost everything depends on it — you have to change that: you have to start identifying supporters and opponents, get them on the record. And you have to start doing it today because if you don’t you’ll roll into 2029 in the exact same situation, with this intractable barrier to progress which isn’t going anywhere any time soon.
Sanders offers the alternative of passing a reconciliation bill, which avoids the filibuster and so needs only a majority vote. But since you only get one or two shots at a reconciliation bill each year, they are the kind of big omnibus bills that are easy to veto. A targeted raise-the-minimum-wage bill is harder, because people know exactly what it means. Without the filibuster, you can make Trump veto something popular every week.
Democrats in Congress have an important decision to make before the new Congress takes office in January: The government runs out of money on December 11. Republicans will want to either pass another continuing resolution or push through a full-year budget. The big issue here is the Iran War: Should Democrats try to defund it now, and risk a government shutdown that will stretch through the holidays? Or wait for reinforcements to arrive in January? What’s the shortest continuing resolution that won’t spark a shutdown?
I’d like to hear Schumer and Van Hollen explain their strategies here.